What College Coaches Look For (Its not just talent)

cosette93
Sep 19
2 min read

When high school athletes dream about playing at the next level, most assume talent is the only thing that matters...while skill is important, many athletes overlook what truly sets a recruit apart.

College coaches aren’t just evaluating players. They’re evaluating people.

Whether you're a junior trying to get on the radar or a freshman just getting started, here are 7 things that coaches are really looking for beyond the box score.

1. Body Language on the Sidelines

You might think no one is watching when you’re not in the game, but they are.

Coaches notice how you:

Support your teammates from the bench
Respond after a mistake
Carry yourself when you’re losing or not getting playing time

How you act when you're not in the spotlight says a lot about who you are as a teammate and as a person

2. Coachability

Talent opens the door, but coachability keeps it open.

Coaches want athletes who:

Listen and make adjustments quickly
Take criticism without attitude
Put in consistent effort regardless of playing time

They ask your high school and club coaches about your attitude. If you're known as difficult to coach, it will hurt your chances, no matter how skilled you are.

3. Academic Habits

Grades matter; not just for eligibility but for showing discipline and maturity.

Coaches look at:

GPA and class attendance
How you manage school and sports
Whether you're likely to stay eligible and succeed in college

A strong academic record shows you're serious about your responsibilities and that you’ll be dependable in a college environment.

4. Hustle on Every Play

Effort doesn’t show up on a stat sheet, but it’s one of the first things coaches notice on film.

They look for athletes who:

Sprint on and off the field or the court
Compete for every play, not just the big moments
Stay locked in regardless of the score

Highlight reels show talent. Game film shows effort and consistency.

5. Communication and Presence

How do you carry yourself in pressure situations? How do you talk to teammates, coaches, refs, and opponents?

Coaches watch for:

Leadership and accountability
Poise under pressure
Respectful and mature communication

You don’t have to be the loudest voice, but you should be someone others want to follow.

6. Social Media Behavior

Yes, college coaches check your posts.

They pay attention to:

What you post and share
How you respond to others online
Whether your presence reflects maturity or creates red flags

Think of your social media as part of your personal brand, make sure it represents the person and player you want coaches to see.

7. Consistency

One good tournament or viral play is not enough. Coaches are looking for athletes who perform consistently over time.

They value:

Steady progress season to season
Dependability in different game situations
Athletes who stay locked in from start to finish

They don’t need you to be perfect, they need you to be dependable.

Final Thought: Character Is a Stat

The athletes who stand out aren’t just physically gifted, they’re respectful, driven, reliable, and coachable. They lead, they compete the right way, and they represent themselves well on and off the field.

If you want to be recruited, start acting like a college athlete now, not later.